
I finally started playing Mass Effect a few days ago. About 5 hours into the game and i have some mixed feelings about it. Things started to go wrong from the start.
Let me explain. When choosing your character’s class you are given 6 options. But after reading some reviews and listening to podcasts it was clear to me that apart from the Soldier and Vanguard classes the other 4 were somewhat broken. It made finishing the game from normal to extremely difficult and frustrating. To be honest if i had not known about this i would have chosen either the Engineer or the Infiltrator. Instead i chose the Soldier. I find it incredible that a role playing game can miss the balance of classes so much so that it makes the game harder instead of just having a different experience.
Once i made the remaining choices in my profile off i went to be finally impressed. I love the dialog tree from Bioware and although not revolutionary it is a great touch combined with the fact that what you choose is the basic context of your conversation and not the exact words. It makes the whole conversation feel more real.
But then there is the actual combat. It feels clumsy and so very gamey. While it is a nice touch to have to use cover, when shooting the controls feel imprecise. Plus, the AI of my squadmates is ridiculous. They keep dying on me and even though i place them in safe poistions, they keep moving on their own and getting killed in the process. Worrying about them takes more of my time than the actually killing of the bad guys.
Then you have your technical issues with the frame drop being an issue throughout the game and the pop ups especially just after a screen has been loaded. I mean come on Bioware…
My last grievance has to be the inventory system. This is one of the most unfriendly RPG inventories i have encountered. I usually like to mess around with the equipment or other items i pick up but to be honest in Mass Effect i hesitate to enter the menus because i have to scroll through all the items i have, even when in dublicate, to find what i want. In addition visually the difference between equipment is not the most accessible it could have been. I am not sure whether it’s the colour or the way these are presented but it just not user friendly.
I might be giving the impression that i am not enjoying Mass Effect. On the contrary, i am enjoying it but when compared to other titles this year (well of 2007) , Mass Effect is doing so many things wrong. I can not accept that it is because it is so ambitious.
Having a decent AI is ambitious? A simple, easy to use inventory is ambitious? An RPG which is restricting your choice of characters due to the inconsistency of difficulty is because of its ambitions? Bad impressions indeed.